Planck Standard
Physics

Superconducting Vortices Give First Experimental Proof That Clogging Is a Phase Transition

Researchers at the Institute of Science Tokyo showed that jams in flowing particles behave like a phase transition, sharing a critical point with depinning.

Superconducting Vortices Give First Experimental Proof That Clogging Is a Phase Transition
Image via Phys.org

Anyone who has watched a drain back up or a crowd jam a doorway has seen clogging. Physicists have predicted for years that the move from smooth flow to a complete blockage is a true phase transition, but nobody had proved it in an experiment. Researchers at the Institute of Science Tokyo have now done so, using vortices in a superconductor. Their results appeared in Communications Physics in September and were publicized this month.

Clogging happens when moving particles hit a bottleneck that slows or stops the flow. It shows up in granular materials, filters, industrial pipelines and biological transport networks such as blood vessels. Earlier computer simulations predicted that the change from flowing to fully clogged is a nonequilibrium phase transition, in which the time needed to settle into a steady flowing or blocked state grows without limit near a critical point. Experiments had not confirmed it.

The team, led by former graduate student Takahide Minemura and professor emeritus Satoshi Okuma, studied vortices in thin films of amorphous molybdenum-germanium driven by a direct current. In a superconductor, magnetic field lines thread through the material as vortices. Defects in the film act as pinning sites that hold vortices in place, and trapped vortices can form bottlenecks that block others, producing clogging.

The hard part was telling clogging apart from ordinary pinning. The researchers built a two-step measurement protocol using successive current drives, applied either in the same direction or in opposite directions. By tracking the voltage as it changed over time, they could follow vortex motion and separate a fast relaxation tied to clogging from a slower one tied to pinning.

Both relaxation times grew sharply and followed power laws as the driving current approached a critical value. The current at which clogging set in matched the depinning current, the point where vortices break free of their pins, to within experimental uncertainty. The critical exponents also matched predictions for the two-dimensional directed percolation universality class, a type of nonequilibrium phase transition in which activity can die out into an absorbing state.

The upshot is that clogging and depinning share one critical point and show consistent critical behavior, even though they are different dynamical processes. That gives theorists a firm experimental anchor for models of jamming that had so far been tested only on computers.

"Clogging can also cause serious problems in industrial plants, infrastructure pipelines and biological transport systems such as blood vessels," Okuma said. "Although it has been predicted in simulation that the transition from a flowing state to a completely clogged state represents a nonequilibrium phase transition, experimental verification had remained elusive. This was the main motivation of our study."

The team says the findings may help guide work on flow obstruction in granular materials, colloids, active matter and other systems where collective motion can get blocked. Future studies could test how these critical dynamics change across other materials and transport environments, with the longer-term aim of better ways to predict and control clogging in industry, infrastructure and the body.

Read next