Physicists Film Quantum Whirlpools Tangling and Unraveling in an Ultracold Gas
A Cambridge team directly imaged vortex tangles decaying in a Bose-Einstein condensate, confirming a theory called Vinen turbulence that had only been seen indirectly.

A team at the University of Cambridge has caught a tangle of quantum whirlpools unraveling inside an ultracold gas, the first direct observation of a process that theory has predicted for decades. The work, led by Sebastian Morris and published in Physical Review Letters, confirms a picture of quantum fluids known as Vinen turbulence.
When a cloud of atoms is cooled close to absolute zero, the atoms can merge into a Bose-Einstein condensate, an exotic fluid in which the whole cloud shares a single quantum state. Quantum behavior that normally belongs to individual particles then plays out on a large scale. Such a fluid cannot circulate freely the way water does. Any rotation is squeezed into thin, thread-like vortices, each carrying a fixed, quantized amount of circulation.
According to the theory, a freshly formed condensate should contain a chaotic tangle of these threads that gradually untangles as the fluid relaxes. Until now, physicists had seen only hints of this, and mostly in superfluid helium, where the evidence was indirect. In atomic gases, vortices had mostly been imaged in flat, two-dimensional systems. To test the idea in a three-dimensional gas, the researchers had to both see the vortices and count them.
The Cambridge team began with a condensate of potassium atoms held in a uniform, cylinder-shaped trap of light less than a tenth of a millimeter across. They first disturbed the gas to scramble its ordered state, then switched on interactions between the atoms and let the system relax. At different moments during the relaxation they released the gas, magnified it about 3.5 times and photographed a thin slice of the enlarged cloud. In those images, vortices appeared as dark streaks where the threads crossed the slice.
Repeating the process many times let the team estimate the total length of vortex thread packed into each unit of volume. That allowed a direct test of the law describing how the quantity should shrink over time. The vortex density fell just as Vinen turbulence predicts, with denser tangles decaying faster because neighboring vortices interact with each other. Later, the decay slowed as the remaining vortices were lost at the walls of the trap.
Two details stand out. The decay did not depend on how strongly the atoms interacted with each other. And once the researchers accounted for the difference in particle mass, the rate closely matched measurements in superfluid helium, even though the two fluids are completely different at the microscopic level. That suggests the behavior is a general property of quantum fluids rather than a quirk of one system.
The vortices also became clearly visible at about the same time the atoms began to show a growing pattern of quantum coherence. That ties the untangling of the threads to the way the condensate emerges from disorder, which is the larger question behind the experiment.
For physicists, the result moves a long-standing prediction from the blackboard to a direct observation. It also gives them a cleaner tool for studying turbulence, one of the hardest problems in physics, in a fluid where every vortex can be counted.





