Planck Standard
Science

Astronomers Find a Likely Neutron Star Heavier Than Theory Says Is Easy to Make

The unseen companion of a red giant, J0008+0128, weighs about 2.2 suns, sits in a wide 3.3-year orbit, and none of 300,000 simulations could build a system like it.

Astronomers Find a Likely Neutron Star Heavier Than Theory Says Is Easy to Make
Image via Phys.org

Astronomers have found a red giant star circling something invisible and unusually heavy, an object that is most likely a neutron star but sits right at the edge of how massive such stars are thought to get. The system, called J0008+0128, is reported in Science Advances and has defeated every attempt so far to explain how it formed.

The team spotted the system using data from China's Large Sky Area Multi-Object Fiber Spectroscopic Telescope, known as LAMOST, and the Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment, or APOGEE. The companion cannot be seen, but its gravity tugs on the red giant in ways the telescopes can measure. Hunting for hidden companions this way is routine. The mass and orbit of this one are not.

Neutron stars are the dense remnants of exploded high-mass stars. They typically weigh about 1.4 times the mass of the sun, packed into a sphere roughly 20 kilometers, or 12 miles, across. No neutron star above 2.5 solar masses has been found so far. Black holes, left by even larger stars, are typically at least five solar masses. That leaves an odd gap of roughly 2.5 to 5 solar masses where astronomers are unsure what exists. The maximum mass of a neutron star depends on how matter behaves under the extreme pressures in its interior, and the equations describing that are still poorly understood. Rare, heavy examples help show where neutron stars give way to black holes.

The researchers estimate the unseen companion's mass at between 1.8 and 2.8 solar masses, with a best estimate of 2.2 solar masses. The top of that range reaches into the gap. The pair completes an orbit in about 3.3 years, which means the two objects are far apart, and the orbit is surprisingly close to circular. No light was detected beyond that of the red giant, so the companion cannot be an ordinary star.

That combination is what makes the system hard to explain. Many other heavy neutron stars live in tight binaries and probably gained mass by pulling gas from their partners. This one is too far from the red giant to do that, and none of the usual signs of mass transfer are present.

The team ran about 300,000 simulations of isolated binary stars with the POSYDON code to see how such a pair might form. None reproduced the masses and orbit together. The authors write that the scarcity of similar systems "points to a strong evolutionary bias within isolated binary evolution," though they add that formation is not ruled out and might require extreme but plausible conditions, such as an unusually efficient ejection of the star's outer envelope, a high birth mass for the neutron star and a minimal kick from the supernova.

The closest comparison is Gaia NS1, a neutron star candidate of about 1.9 solar masses in a roughly two-year orbit. J0008+0128 looks a little more extreme. The team says other explanations exist but fit less well. The system could be a triple, with two close, smaller neutron stars or a neutron star and a white dwarf orbiting inside the pair, or it may once have been a triple whose two smaller members merged. A very small black hole is also possible, though none that small has ever been identified.

More observations of the system could narrow those options. For now it gives theorists a concrete object to test their models against, and a reason to rework the ones that cannot make it.

Read next