Italy Fines Meta $880 Million Over Facebook App's Access to Users' Photos
The data protection authority says Meta pulled photos, videos and metadata from Italian users' Android phones without specific consent or proper notice.

Italy's data protection authority has fined Meta $880 million, saying the company's Facebook app on Android phones accessed Italian users' photos, videos and related metadata without getting their specific consent and without properly telling them.
The regulator announced the penalty Saturday. It said the access happened through the Facebook Android app and that Meta failed on two counts: it did not obtain specific consent from users, and it did not adequately inform them about what the app was doing with their media files.
The fine is among the largest an Italian authority has ever imposed on a technology giant. For comparison, Italy's competition regulator fined Amazon more than 1.1 billion euros, about $1.2 billion, in 2021 for breaching competition law. That penalty was reduced on appeal to 752 million euros, about $829 million.
Meta had not responded to a request for comment by Saturday afternoon. The company can appeal the decision, as Amazon did. Companies often challenge large European privacy penalties in court, and the final amounts can change.
The ruling adds to a run of legal setbacks for Meta over how it handles user data and children's safety. In September, a New Mexico judge ordered Meta to pay the state $25 billion after a jury found the company had deceived consumers about its data privacy policies for years. Meta said it disagreed with that verdict. Late last month, the company also settled a teen social media addiction case weeks before a Los Angeles trial was set to begin.
Italy's regulator has a history of moving quickly against large platforms, and European data protection authorities have the power to levy fines based on a share of a company's global revenue under the bloc's privacy law. Italian authorities have previously acted against other technology companies over data practices, and a number of European regulators have focused on how apps obtain consent before reaching into the personal files stored on a phone.
The finding goes to a question many users never think about: what a social media app can see on a phone once it is installed. Photos and videos carry location data, timestamps and other metadata that can reveal a great deal about a person's life. The Italian authority's position is that reaching into that material requires clear, specific permission and plain explanation, not a general agreement buried in terms of service.
Whether the fine survives an appeal is unclear. What is clear is the size of the number and the message behind it. Regulators in Europe are willing to attach nine-figure penalties to what an app does with the files on a person's phone.


