Planck Standard
Politics

Alito Warns Congress Could 'Turn Off the Lights' on the Supreme Court

Speaking at the Federalist Society's black-tie dinner, the justice called the judiciary the 'least dangerous' branch and criticized lower-court orders blocking the president.

Alito Warns Congress Could 'Turn Off the Lights' on the Supreme Court
Image via NBC News

Justice Samuel Alito told a room of more than 2,500 conservative lawmakers, lawyers and judges Thursday night that the Supreme Court is far more vulnerable than its reputation suggests, warning that Congress holds the power to halt its work by cutting off money.

Alito spoke at the Federalist Society's National Lawyers Convention black-tie dinner in Washington on Nov. 12, in a conversation with conservative author Mollie Hemingway. NBC News reported his remarks Friday. He described the judiciary as the "least dangerous" branch, one exposed to pressure from a president and a Congress that he said hold more power. Congress, he said, has "many, many, many other things" it could do or try to do to the courts, including refusing to fund their operations.

He pushed back on the idea that the Court wields something like a "nuclear weapon" or a "500-pound bomb." Alito called it a "hand grenade": the least dangerous branch, he said, but still a dangerous one.

The justice also took aim at lower federal courts. He said some judges have gone "far astray" by issuing what he called "unjustified orders." He added that the judges are dedicated and skilled but make mistakes like anyone else.

Alito laid out a pattern he sees on the Court's emergency docket. Presidents frustrated with Congress, he said, increasingly act on their own. Opponents then sue in favorable districts, and judges often block the policy while appeals drag on, sometimes for years. That sequence, he suggested, pulls the Supreme Court into disputes before the usual process has run its course.

He did not directly mention the midterm elections, which Democrats won last week, taking control of both the House and the Senate by larger margins than expected. But the timing was hard to miss. A Democratic Congress will control the budget process, and Alito's remark about Congress being able to "turn off the lights" came days after that result.

The Trump administration has won most of its emergency applications at the Court's conservative-majority "shadow docket," NBC News noted, in areas including immigration enforcement, restructuring of the federal workforce and construction at the White House ballroom. Alito, who was nominated by President George W. Bush, has been on the Court since 2006.

The appearance fits a broader pattern of justices speaking publicly as the Court faces criticism from both sides over its handling of President Trump's agenda and over how quickly it acts on emergency requests.

Read next