Planck Standard
Politics

Judge Blocks Closure of DC's East Potomac Park and Golf Course Until Nov. 28

Judge Ana Reyes says the government's reasons look pretextual, and she's opening an inquiry into whether officials misrepresented facts. Trump says he'll appeal immediately.

Judge Blocks Closure of DC's East Potomac Park and Golf Course Until Nov. 28
Image via CBS News

A federal judge on Saturday temporarily blocked the Trump administration from closing East Potomac Park and its public golf course in Washington, D.C., a day before the government planned to shut the grounds and begin a redesign.

U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes issued the order, which lasts until November 28. She did not require the government to actively manage the park or the course. The plaintiffs are a D.C. preservation group and two local golfers, supported by a coalition that includes Democracy Forward.

The administration had planned to close the park on November 15 so the course could be rebuilt with a championship-style layout by golf architect Tom Fazio, with reopening expected in about 15 months. The National Park Service cut down more than 500 trees last month. Reyes then barred further tree removal and required the Justice Department to give notice of future actions at the course.

Officials have pointed to a deteriorating sea wall, safety risks, and the fact that the National Links Trust, which operates the courses, is due to stop operating on November 15. The sea wall repair is estimated to cost more than $300 million and take at least two and a half years, and the Park Service has no current repair plan.

Reyes was skeptical. She found the justifications appeared pretextual, writing that "the Government reverse-engineers additional justifications for the Park's closure." She also questioned why the park wasn't closed immediately if the situation were truly an emergency.

President Trump said the course is in "a terrible state of disrepair" and that the administration "will immediately appeal, on an expedited basis." A Justice Department spokesperson said the ruling acknowledged that the Park Service can limit access where the public faces harm, and that planning for the new course can continue. Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward said he "would be shocked to learn there is a contract" with Fazio's firm.

Reyes also opened a separate inquiry into whether officials misrepresented facts or violated ethics rules. She intends to have former U.S. Attorney Jessie Liu lead it, and the Justice Department opposes that appointment.

The case adds to a string of legal fights over Trump's building plans in the capital. The National Capital Planning Commission is scheduled to consider the new course proposal on December 3, five days after the judge's order is set to expire.

Until the order expires, the park and its public golf course stay open to the people who use them, and the Park Service can still limit access where it finds the public faces harm. The judge gave the government no instruction to spend money on the grounds in the meantime, and the planning for the new course can continue in parallel.

Read next