Planck Standard
Physics

New Theory Explains How Fusion Plasma Snaps Into High-Confinement Mode

Swiss physicists say they have solved a 40-year puzzle, predicting how much heating power ITER and SPARC will need to reach the state that makes fusion practical.

New Theory Explains How Fusion Plasma Snaps Into High-Confinement Mode
Image via Phys.org / EPFL

Physicists at EPFL's Swiss Plasma Center say they have built a theory that explains how a fusion plasma suddenly jumps into a much better-insulated state, a puzzle that has stood since 1982. The work, led by doctoral assistant Brenno De Lucca, appears in Physical Review Letters.

Fusion promises energy by combining light atomic nuclei, the same process that powers the sun. To do it on Earth, scientists heat a gas until it becomes plasma, then must keep it hot and stable long enough for fusion to pay off. One approach uses tokamaks, machines that hold the plasma inside a doughnut-shaped chamber with powerful magnetic fields. The trouble is turbulence: fluctuations carry heat out of the plasma and make the needed conditions hard to maintain.

In 1982, researchers found that raising the heating power past a threshold triggers an abrupt change. Turbulence near the plasma's edge falls sharply, and the plasma holds its energy far better. The shift from low confinement, called L-mode, to high confinement, called H-mode, is essential for future reactors such as ITER, the largest international fusion project. Yet nobody could reliably predict the heating power needed to trigger it. The threshold shifts with plasma density and with the direction of the magnetic field, and existing theories could not explain both effects together.

The EPFL team ran computer simulations of a tokamak plasma as heating power increased, identified the physical processes behind the transition, built a mathematical model and checked its predictions against measurements from existing tokamaks. They found that turbulence itself generates flows that move at different speeds across the plasma's outer region, and those differences help suppress the turbulence, cutting heat loss.

The model also explains why magnetic field direction matters. Its calculations show that the field direction, the plasma flows and collisions between particles combine to make the transition easier in one magnetic configuration than the other. The team derived equations for how the power threshold changes with density, including why the required power rises with density in one regime and falls in another, which creates a density where the heating requirement is lowest.

Applying the model to future machines, the researchers predict ITER, under construction in France, would need at least 43 megawatts of heating power to reach H-mode, below its planned 73-megawatt capacity. For SPARC, the compact high-field tokamak being developed by the U.S. company Commonwealth Fusion Systems, the predicted minimum is 26 megawatts, close to its planned 25-megawatt capacity, leaving much less room for error.

The paper, titled "Theory for the Power Threshold of the L-H Transition in Tokamaks," gives reactor designers a physics-based way to estimate the operating conditions they need, rather than extrapolating from older experiments.

Read next