Planck Standard
Politics

Justice Department Asks Court to Erase Its Failed Lawsuit Over Alaska's Senate Race

Two days after Mary Peltola's win was decided, DOJ lawyers say there is no longer any way to determine whether votes for 'Daniel J. Sullivan' were meant for Sen. Dan Sullivan, and ask the 9th Circuit to declare the case moot.

Justice Department Asks Court to Erase Its Failed Lawsuit Over Alaska's Senate Race
Image via CBS News

The Trump administration has moved to dismiss its own lawsuit over Alaska's Senate race, asking a federal appeals court on Thursday to declare the case moot two days after the contest was decided. The Justice Department filed the suit at President Trump's direction, arguing that a win by Democrat Mary Peltola should not be certified until an investigation could determine whether voters were confused by a second candidate on the ballot.

In its filing, the department urged the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to overturn the lower court's dismissal of the case, vacate that order, and then dismiss the case anyway. The lawyers wrote that the court "should hold that this case is moot, vacate the underlying order, and remand for dismissal on that ground." The request would effectively erase the administration's loss in the lower court.

The filing contains an unusual concession. "The United States therefore reluctantly acknowledges that there no longer exists any means of 'determin[ing] whether votes cast for Daniel J. Sullivan were meant to be cast for Senator Sullivan,'" Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward wrote. The administration never explained how such an investigation could take place given the secrecy of the ballot.

Attorneys for the state of Alaska, which is currently controlled by Republicans, also objected to the administration's case. They called it legally "meritless" and filed papers to help get the initial case dismissed. That put the state on the opposite side of the federal government in a dispute over how Alaska runs and certifies its own elections.

Peltola said it was time to move on. "Now that the election is over and the voters sent a very clear message about the direction they want our state to go in, I'm eager to move forward and get to work on behalf of all Alaskans," she said in a statement. The Associated Press, which reported on the filing, also left messages for Sen. Sullivan's campaign and the Alaska Department of Law seeking comment.

The lawsuit was one piece of a broader federal push. Trump has demanded that Peltola be prosecuted over the decoy-candidate scheme, and federal investigators swarmed into Alaska before Election Day. Tricks involving decoy candidates, in which a second candidate with a similar name appears on a ballot to draw votes, have been a staple of U.S. politics for decades, and Trump's allies have also used them, though occasionally such schemes lead to criminal charges.

The move was at least the second time since the Nov. 3 election that the Justice Department has acted to dismiss one of its own high-profile lawsuits interfering in states' handling of their elections. Whether the 9th Circuit will agree to vacate the lower court's ruling, rather than simply let it stand, is the open question, and the state's opposition makes that outcome less certain.

Read next