Planck Standard
Politics

Cornyn Kills Trump's Pick for a Dallas Judgeship: 'He's Not a Texan'

The Texas Republican withheld his blue slip on Justice Department official T. Elliot Gaiser, saying the White House tried to 'jam the Senate' and his nomination is 'no longer viable.'

Cornyn Kills Trump's Pick for a Dallas Judgeship: 'He's Not a Texan'
Image via CBS News

Republican Sen. John Cornyn of Texas has blocked President Trump's nomination of T. Elliot Gaiser, a top Justice Department official, for a seat on the federal district court in the Dallas area, CBS News reported. Cornyn told CBS on Capitol Hill that he declined to return a so-called blue slip for Gaiser, which effectively derails the nomination in the Senate Judiciary Committee.

"I think his nomination is no longer viable," Cornyn said. Asked why, he said: "He's not a Texan, has no trial experience, and the White House tried to jam the Senate and wouldn't allow us to do our due diligence that we need to do on lifetime appointments." Gaiser was expected to appear at a Judiciary Committee confirmation hearing on Wednesday, but he was not among the seven judicial candidates who testified.

The blue-slip process is meant to force consultation between the White House and the home-state senators of a nominee. For the Dallas-area vacancy on the Northern District of Texas, those senators are Cornyn and fellow Republican Ted Cruz. A district court nominee can get a hearing only if both return positive blue slips. President Trump has pushed Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley, an Iowa Republican, to scrap the policy, but Grassley has kept it in place for district court and U.S. attorney nominations.

Speaking Tuesday at The Atlantic Summit, Cornyn was blunter about the process. "The Constitution provides for advice and consent, but there was no consultation whatsoever, no attempt to try to work with the Senate," he said. "I've offered an alternative, but we'll see whether they take us up on it. But I think the Senate's not supposed to be a rubber stamp and ... we have been too often."

The timeline in Gaiser's own paperwork shows how fast the White House moved. Gaiser told the committee in a questionnaire that Cruz's staff first contacted him about the vacancy on Nov. 4, one day after Democrats' sweeping midterm victories. He discussed a possible nomination with Cornyn's office on Nov. 6, and the White House Counsel's Office told him that same day that the president was considering him. His questionnaire is dated Nov. 7. Mr. Trump announced the pick on Nov. 10, and the nomination was formally sent to the Senate on Monday.

Gaiser does not live in Texas. A native of Ohio who served as that state's solicitor general, he joined the administration last year as head of the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel. His only apparent tie to Texas is a one-year clerkship in Houston for a judge on the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

His work at the Office of Legal Counsel has drawn criticism. Gaiser wrote the opinion justifying U.S. military strikes on alleged drug-smuggling boats in the eastern Pacific and the Caribbean. In an April opinion he said the Presidential Records Act, which requires presidents to preserve documents and hand them to the National Archives, is unconstitutional. An August opinion concluded that Mr. Trump's outside advisers are shielded from future congressional and legal investigations because communications with private outsiders are generally covered by executive privilege.

The fight comes as the Judiciary Committee races to confirm as many of Mr. Trump's judicial nominees as possible during the lame-duck session that follows the Nov. 3 midterms. Democrats are poised to hold 56 Senate seats when the new Congress convenes in January, so few, if any, of the president's remaining picks to the appeals and district courts are expected to be confirmed after that.

Read next